Great location on a side street in the heart of Ocracoke off Route 12. The room was nice (wife said "cute"). We chose the room in the "loft" which worked well for us traveling lite and being able to handle the stairs. We spent most of our time exploring Ocracoke, so we did not take full advantage of the pool or game room.

The only thing that seemed a little over priced was the rental of on-site golf carts compared to the prices at other rental places.

Central location being close to everything. Love the balconys/porches. Bed was comfortable. Lots of channels on tv I appreciated. Cleaning stafe was quick and good. Love the decor charm of the lobby. LOVE all the sweet kitty’s!

Wish the outside common area where the 2 rickety picnic benches were was just a little nicer.

Room was clean and organized, just like the images! Front staff was kind enough to wait 15 minutes after office hours since ferry was running 15 minutes late. I was able to communicate with them through the booking agency and also directly about my booking and they were always helpful and nice over messages/phone call.

Limited parking area but we did arrive late on Labor Day weekend so that is understandable. Also found 1 bug on the wall in the closet but the staff had left bug spray which we were so happy that it was there !!! (also the lodge is located in a wooded area so the bug being in the room was not a surprise).

Even though the building is a bit dated, you can see all the effort that has been made to freshen the rooms up. Our room was beautiful and clean with a very comfortable bed.

For as nice as the rooms were- I was disappointed with the pool. The pool deck needs to be sprayed for ants and the pool itself doesn’t look clean due to staining on the bottom.

Pretty close to everything, I like how they keep it in its vintage era of old school hotels … older yet nostalgic. It was seriously nothing special but it was clean, the beds were super comfortable, and our room amenities were exactly what we wanted- especially having 2 bathrooms and a covered balcony- which we needed dues to rain.

Golf cart charger situation - 2 outlets with multiple extension chords and probably 8 carts attached. Mine didn’t even charge - the breaker probably tripped.

Love the charm, location and the friendly staff.

Disliked the behavior of couple in the unit next door. Obviously, over served themselves and the man was NOT able to control his temper. The bickering and arguing went on pretty much all night, into the wee hours.

Great location, property has a good flow to it. Movement from the parking lot to the lobby to the guest rooms is smooth.

Noisy neighbors, getting in late and leaving early while letting the doors slam

Location was great. Could walk from the ferry coming to Ocracoke from Swan Quarter if desired. Facilities were older but I loved the ambience. The facilities matched the hotels name. The staff was great.

Parking wasn't well marked. Kinda make your own space but no one seemed to mind.

Awesome staff! So welcoming. The lodge and the island was like stepping back in time no hustle, bustle lots of rocking chairs, which we enjoyed.

The weather, but we made the best of it

The staff were very professional and very nice. They answered all our questions and were very helpful. Our room was comfortable and very clean. We would definitely stay with them again.

There was nothing about Blackbeard’s Lodge we didn’t like.