Quite unexpected and absolutley fabulous. In the middle of nowhere, wonderful views and silence so quiet you could hear it. We arrived to a Barbecue night so one would be forgiven for expecting overcooked charcoaled food but the range of choice was extensive and perfectly cooked by the owner - clearly an expert BBQ-er. Rooms were spotless , the breakfast buffet was extensive and fresh.. We would have stayed longer if we had the time. As the guide Michelin would say "Vaut le Voyage"

the only (very minor) criticism would be the terrible orange juice. Hardly anywhere serves decent fresh orange juice . I would have gladly paid an extra Euros5.00 per night for good quality orange juice at breakfast. Otherwise the stay couldn't have been more perfect.

We messed up on our reservation and the owner was SUPER accommodating - above and beyond. Our rooms were super comfortable and both had a balcony with a great view. Outside of town, so super quiet and you can hike the Black Forest directly from the hotel and still have a close drive to Feldberg, Titisee, Triberg, etc. Breakfast was a standard German buffet and everything was excellent. We were surprised to arrive at the hotel in the evening and see lots of local cars in the parking lot, but realized it was for the great dinner. Inexpensive and fantastic!

Only showers (no tub) in the rooms, but we knew that from the reservation.

Lovely location in the hills outside Titisee, excellent restaurant, both for evening meals and continental breakfast. All staff very friendly and helpful, location very bike friendly

Nothing at all! The only thing to be aware of in this general area is that almost all places to eat are closed on Tuesdays

Hosts were lovley. Allowed me to park my motorcycle in a dry shelter/garage. Room was comfortable, facilities were in place, quiet location and nice breakfast. Had a nice selction of food for evening meal.

Nothing really, met my expectations.

It's located in a very beautiful landscape, the breakfast was quite good and the staff were so friendly. It was a good experience for the price. As it's a Schwarzwald-style old house, you might hear some creaking from others walking on the wooden floors, but for me, it adds to the charm and authenticity of the experience.

Nothing

Super friendly owners. Let us park our motorcycles in the garage. Great dinner menu selection of Black Forest favorites! Super tasty and great view from terrace during dinner. Super service and good breakfast too! Definitely recommend. We will be back!

Really classic Gastaus. The restaurant served typical a Black Forest menu.People come from all over to go to the restaurant even tho it's not in Neustadt. Breakfast was served on the balcony & was delicious. A complete German breakfast. Our room was large & comfortable with a small balcony. Bed huge with comforters.

Everything was a perfect Gasthaus experience.

the room was clean, warm and spacious, the bed was very comfortable. the staff is very kind and friendly too.

some friends recommended us the food here, but it was so salty that I could eat less than half, my tongue started hurting, despite the beer! at breakfast I tried the same ingredients (sausages and eggs) to see if it was the base ingredient salty or the chef, and I confirm it was the chef. too bad! not very nice that you cannot charge the dinner on the room.

The staff were very polite and helpful,the food in the restaurant was of a high standard will definitely make a return visit. Well done to everyone

Amazing location and what a view at breakfast. Had a problem with our car (a stone marten had chewed though an intake pipe, apparently this is a thing in the black forest 😂). Owner was great, containing the garage for us and booking in. Garage were amazing too, repaired at no cost. Evening meals great, breakfast a nice buffet selection of good quality cheese, bread, eggs etc. Very comfy beds.

Not a moan, but just for information the evening restaurant is closed on Tuesdays so don't plan to eat at the guesthouse.