I slept in the Overlook Lodge. The room was clean and the view on the lake was amazing. Even if outside was pretty cold, the room was warm and very clean. I had no problem parking neither at the Inn and at the Lodge. Even with the snow and the ice, with the car was easy to reach both location. Other than the room, I tired the services of both the Hikers' Cafe and the second floor bar. They were both very good in terms of price-quality ratio, with plenty of possible choices. The location, generally speaking, is amazing. The staff was helpful and easy going.

Nothing, it was perfect.

Clean, comfortable and very spacious rooms with exceptional views. Super- cozy and rustic,yet modern,decor. In room Keurig coffee maker, amazing TV,very comfortable pillows and beds as well as a great sitting chair. Staff in the dining room were all amazing! -personable, efficient and professional. Mid- week afternoon tea was exceptional and very reasonably priced compared to elsewhere. The quality of our dinner was 5/5 stars- so delicious. We got the salmon and the organic chicken dish with a side of “not to be missed” mashed potatoes. Both entrees were very tasty and beautifully portioned,presented and cooked. The bar and tavern area also offers awesome lunch items and full bar. Go for the French onion soup. I had it 2 times! The grounds offer so much- hiking, ice skating , a surprisingly awesome zoo and an outdoor sort -of -archaeological and historical museum area with very professional exhibits and spectacular views of the mountains and the Bear Mountain Bridge as you stroll though paved paths in a nicely forested park like area. Overall a wonderful winter getaway with so much comfort and Nature to offer.

Better / more breakfast options in the main lodge dining room besides brunch and grab and go options. For example a reasonably priced buffet or blueberry pancakes or eggs combos or oatmeal and fruit etc.

The location is outstanding ! The Overlook Lodge is in a wooded area, and there is a wonderful view from the common area balcony. The rustic decor and furniture is unique and comfortable and appealing. The park offers hiking trails and a lot of open space. The common area living room has,a huge stone fireplace. Delightful !!

We purchased take out dinner. That was a bit disappointing. That would not deter me from returning.

The area is beautiful and just far enough away from NYC but still close enough to visit. The Inn is gorgeous. I love all the history in the area. It's been updated and clean. We ate at the Hikers Cafe, and the food was good. Staff was all friendly and helpful. The stone cabins are really cute. Loved the fireplace in the sitting area. The walls are paper thin, though.

The signage for check-in was lacking and a bit confusing. The sign for the Inn is right over the door for the gift shop and cafe. There should be a sign for check-in over the door between the sets of stairs. It's fall, and I get leaves are an issue, but the underbrush behind the cabins could be cleaned up for a better view.

I liked it very much !! from the front desk to the police patrol amazing experience. A very special Thank you to Sean in the front desk for making me feel so special . So professional and accommodating. Everything was nice and clean The restaurant staff where nice and professional , Great food and drinks. The park was so full of life all different cultures having family and friends gathering So much love in the green grass and the cleanest of the park .

The location was beautiful & quiet, the rooms were comfy and had lovely Nature views. Wifi was good, and bottled water & coffee facility in the room was nice.

We did not use the breakfast option as it was an extra charge & the selection was not attractive. No lift option to our second floor rooms in the Overlook Lodge was difficult with several suitcases. Check-in at a different location was also inconvenient

Location, clean and comfortable.

I wish the Inn had more amenities on site, considering it is separate from the main building. Perhaps a simple complimentry breakfast, small bar. We would have enjoyed a warm fire burning in the cozy large lounge area. Especially because it was a holiday weekend and very busy.

Location was excellent. Breakfast was fine.

Overlook Lodge was in a great location. Woodwork in the rooms, e.g. bedstead, was beautiful. No fan in the bathroom. Rest of the decor in the rooms was like a modest motel. We had asked online for accommodation in the Stone Cottages but were booked into the Overlook Lodge.

Beautiful cozy hotel, great location for going on walks in the surrounding area. Staff were so friendly and really made our stay.

We loved the historic buildings and the history of the lodge. We also enjoyed the outdoors activities which can be undertaken and the fact that you feel as if you are hundreds of miles outside the city.