Very lovely space and incredible attention to detail in terms of maintaining the victorian vibe. Breakfast was of the continental variety, simple but well-rounded. The bar downstairs, Phatsy Kline's, is an amazing spot to spend a few hours--excellent cocktails too! It's a short walk to the shops and eateries in old town, and a short drive to many of the celebrated sights of the county. In terms of lodging options in and around Eureka, this is an excellent choice for its storied history, welcoming ambiance, and quaint decor.

The rooms facing 2nd street overlook a rough part of the downtown area. Each night of our stay, there was some kind of ruckus in the wee hours: an individual screaming while dumping out trash bins, a group of people shouting louder and louder as they went their separate ways, and, on the final morning, a woman screaming incredibly racist, profane threats. We could hear these instances through the closed windows and were not too bothered, able to go back to sleep once it calmed down; however, light sleepers would likely be uncomfortable.

We liked how we were received initially. The receptionist was so friendly. Our room was amazing. It was so big and the bed was very comfortable. The ceilings throughout the hotel are a work of art. There was much to look at and admire just on our way to our room. The added bonus was that the Friday night fair was going on so we were able to walk straight from our hotel to see what people were selling at the booths within a few minutes.

N/A

Beautiful, historical hotel preserved as if in aspic in 1888 with magnificent antique furniture and fittings. Like staying in the 19th century. The lady at reception was lovely and could not have been kinder or more friendly or helpful. We had a superb meal in Tavern 1888 as a great surprise bonus. Real gourmet food.

Beautiful hotel in a lovely physical location near the water but there were a lot of crazed, ranting addicts on the streets in the immediate area. I felt sorry for the and they didn't bother us but they created an air of menace in the area so we didn't venture out on the night of our one night stay. We just stayed in the beautiful hotel and enjoyed our great meal.

This hotel truly is one of a kind! Sure, a little dated here and there but that is to be expected. After all, this is a historic property. The front desk and maintenance staff was extremely friendly and helpful. We stayed in the King Suite (3rd floor) and loved it. Location is perfect. Right by the Marina (book the harbor cruise!) and the charming DT area. We also had dinner at the in-house restaurant (Tavern) and can only recommend it.

Unfortunately, we did not have a chance to check out the breakfast options as it is not available until 8am.

This is a gorgeous building. It somehow seems simultaneously steeped in history while being restored, clean, and comfortable. There are good restaurants nearby.

We liked this, but maybe not everyone will. We arrived late to find our key on the front desk, it was very easy to get in and do the pickup. We were trying to be quiet and missed the fact that there is an elevator and instead spent a solid 5 minutes trying to get to the fourth floor. The staircases don't connect, and you end up with a tour of the lovely building. So, the elevator is literally right there, use that if you want. But I'd recommend the stairwell adventure!

Location was near the water and we could enjoy the sunset. Appreciated the staff exchanging messages with me when I inquired about elevator and location of the room, as my husband has knee contraints. We were given a room without "steps". The lobby/breakfast area was very pleasant.

Wish the hotel's restaurants were open ... we dined at an okay/fair restaurant that was nearby, but we chose to do this as we were tired from our long drive

I loved the mystery, old style, excellent & friendly staff (Jessica). The building is a maze & it took us a bit to figure out how to navigate around. I loved it! I could have walked around for hours enjoying the photos and nooks and crannies.

No fridge in room or coffee maker, but it didn't matter, because it was set up downstairs & they held our leftovers in their fridge.

Victoria at the front desk was lovely and welcoming. She gave us a little history and background on the hotel. We had room 45 with a view and king bed. Everything was clean and comfortable. The surrounding area was kind of sketchy but the hotel itself was worth it. Super cool antique furniture and vintage vibes.

Surrounding area, the shower had trouble draining but comes with an old building

We had a great room with a great view. Parking was good, but sometimes difficult on the weekend. Hotel is beautiful with a lot of character. Room was well furnished and fits the time of the hotel. Reception was always very friendly and helpful. A light breakfast was an unexpected bonus.

No refrigerator and no micro wave in room. No convenient ice machine. Staff did provide ice upon request.

Great to see the hotel come back to life following the pandemic

Phatsy Cline’s Lounge. My husband almost fell due to not being aware of a step down when you enter the area. They did have a sign, but it wasn’t very obvious. Then the service was very slow and one of the featured items was not available.