Everything I absolutely loved the warm and welcoming atmosphere of the inn. The homey decor and cozy environment made it feel like a true retreat. The cleanliness was impeccable, with fresh linens that had a delightful, clean scent. The staff stood out the most – they were incredibly helpful, polite, and genuinely friendly, always going above and beyond to make my stay comfortable. The overall ambiance was serene and inviting, providing a perfect blend of comfort and excellent service. It was an exceptional experience that exceeded all my expectations.

nothing

What a stunning inn! My sister and I had a lovely two nights here. The staff were friendly and attentive and our room was very comfortable and quiet. There's a lovely garden and living room space that guests can use too: all very peaceful and relaxing. We were lucky to be there on the day that there was the food market in Goshen and enjoyed that. From a location perspective, it's conveniently located off the main road in Goshen, with easy access by car to hiking trails.

The breakfast was a disappointment. Admittedly, the first day we were late coming down so didn't expect much, but the only option was scrambled eggs and bacon, with the addition of banana bread and bananas & oranges on day 2. Not what we were expecting from a "continental breakfast". I had to attend a virtual meeting and the internet was a bit too weak to cope with that, but this isn't the type of place you come to to work, so enjoy & switch off!

Fantastic staff, meals were gourmet and delicious, breakfast included, extremely clean rooms and very comfortable beds.

Our room was located directly over the kitchen and there was a back stairway leading from our 2nd floor hallway down to kitchen. It was only closed off by a curtain. There was no noise, but the kitchen odors came right into our room. They have an air purifier running in the room, but it didn't remove all of the odor. We put a towel under the door the 2nd night, which helped somewhat. I am not sure how they could remedy the problem. I almost hate to complain about this because otherwise everything was perfect, but it was difficult to sleep because of the odor.

The Stagecoach Inn is a luxurious respite. The property is beautifully curated, the rooms are clean and cozy, and Carrie Ann is a true gem. She attended to our every want and need with joy; she made a good experience excellent!

for a premium inn experience the breakfast options were a bit limited in my opinion. bacon and eggs only with some muffins. would have expected pancakes, oatmeal, a good granola as additional choices. having said that, the innkeeper carrieann is a delight, her eggs were good, coffee good. every other aspect of this outing was exceptional.

see above.

Everything! The breakfast was fantastic. The room was clean and comfortable. We had dinner downstairs too and the food was absolutely amazing. This was our second stay at the Stagecoach and we’ll definitely be back.

It was a minor inconvenience, but the wifi kept disconnecting.

The location was perfect - right in the heart of town. They upgraded our room as we were the only guests, and it was lovely. Huge room, immaculately clean, and beautiful decorated. Best night's sleep in a long time! The staff could not have been nicer and more helpful when arranging our breakfast. The breakfast was certainly decent, but I probably would not pay to eat the hot breakfast when staying again. We will be back!

The only thing that could use tweaking is the breakfast.

5 rooms total in this large beautiful inn so you’ll feel like you have the whole place to yourself. Absolutely gorgeous and thoughtful down to very last detail. Most comfortable bed I’ve ever slept in. They make you feel so welcomed, like family. I can’t wait to visit again. A++

Tasteful, clean, charming, welcoming. The room and bed were exquisite, great bathroom and shower too. Delicious hot breakfast. The staff, especially Beverly.

I wasn’t a fan of the pillows.

We always stay in the Margo room. Beautifully decorated with a gas fireplace and a nice soaking tub. The staff is phenomenal. Super friendly and helpful. A very intimate place that I would recommend to anyone searching for a romantic weekend.

Absolutely no complaints. The restaurant is downstairs and yet our room was quiet.