Everything was perfect for our weekend getaway and went far beyond our expectations! The ambience, the mountain views, the staff, the food, it was a dream weekend for my husband and I. The rooms and whole lodge were right out of a movie when you think of a cozy ski resort. The staff were all the sweetest and went above and beyond. We met so many amazing people while staying for the eclipse and everyone was so relaxed and at peace here. The breakfast buffet and dinner at the lodge were excellent. We snow shoed the trails on the property which was a blast. Stargazing right outside our door was unbelievable. We felt right at home here. We will definitely return to Garnet Hill Lodge!

That we didn’t stay longer!

Wonderful location. Great for the athletic and outdoor sports enthusiasts. Restaurant was excellent. Service and staff were very friendly and helpful. Keep in mind this is to be a bit "rustic" as a country lodge. Meet and exceeded our expectations. Hikes to OK Slip Falls and Hudson River (9 miles) and Balm of Gilead (2 miles) are absolutely worth it. Tennis courts were decent (very hot days - and in the sun). Sports center is well stocked with equipment (kayaking, paddle board, tennis, bicycles, etc.). Was a wonderful experience.

Really not much to report here. Please expect the standard of a country lodge with all its "rustic" charms including wildlife. The private beach on Thirteen Lake is best accessed by car - it is a bit of a walk - but we did walk to the beach on our first day. Same is true of the sports center and tennis courts - easiest to get to by car but the walk is considerably shorter than the distance to the private beach. Recommend walking to the tennis courts and sports center, unlike the beach.

The staff was VERY welcoming/friendly. The food was very good and we liked that we could make ourselves sandwiches to take along for the day! The location is beautiful. The history of the lodge is also quite interesting.

The weather didn't cooperate so we really didn't get a chance to hike around. It was rainy, windy, and cold (even snow flurries). It made sitting in front of the huge fireplace more enjoyable :)

Beautiful Adirondack views from our balcony room overlooking Thirteenth Lake. Food was delicious and beyond our expectations. Staff were all very helpful and friendly, seems like a family-run facility with happy staff. Will go back in winter to take advantage of their well-groomed cross country and snowshoe trails. Large equipment shed on property to provide rental equipment.

Parking lot gets muddy, maybe more gravel laid down?

The breakfast was delicious! We were very close to the lake. I wish we would have been able to stay a bit longer. Highly recommended.

The bonfire was out of commission during our stay for repairs, which we would have loved to use. Totally understandable that it was under construction and the staff prepared a fire for us near one of the cabins to make up for it. Excellent service.

The food was amazing. I enjoyed the buffet breakfast and the gleuten free bread. Also the complimentary beverage bar in the lobby. The location is enchanting. The entire staff provided outstanding customer service.

Cannot think of anything that I would change.

Location is beautiful, the lodge is special and rusty, views are amazing, great service and customer experience

Though it is really a wonderful place and we had a great and enjoyable experience, Recommend to improve the following: 1. Breakfast - should implement some variations and add breads, cheese etc. 2. Consider including rooms cleaning and changes of linen/ towels may be changed by staff rather than by guests ( Covid residual practices)

Beautiful resort. Quite atmosphere. High quality buildings and everything set for guests convenience. Sandwiches for lunch were a huge bonus during our ski trips.

Sauna in the room was very small to lie there and the temperature max level was only 65oC.

Breakfast was wonderful, anything I could possibly want! With the bonus of having the ability to create a packed lunch as well! Most people are going hiking, canoeing etc, so this is very thoughtful! Our bathroom was brand new with lux Beekman 1802 bath products, I enjoyed them very much. The view is stunning, next time we will ask for a room w/ a balcony, which is a bit larger. The serenity & peace of this area is wonderful, ALL of the staff bent over backwards to make sure we were happy.

The lodge is from the 1930's so our room was quite small, it took a little time to get used to, we were supplied w/ extra tv tray tables which did help out quite a bit. There was no TV, microwave or fridge, as I am used to having at my other hotel stays, but I quickly realized they weren't as necessary as I thought. The bathroom was beautiful & new but again no place to put anything down, I was able to work around it by putting a tv tray table in there as well.

classic Adirondack lodge in a convenient location with a staff that is first rate.

perhaps a breakfast with more offerings but even that is a stretch