Beautiful hotel, really amazing, friendly and helpful hotel employees. We had few issues with the room after first night and hotel, even that we didn't asked for anything specific - upgraded us to amazing room, so basically we forgot about issues and enjoyed the stay. But anyway, my suggestion is that 5 star hotel can't have such obvious issues with rooms like missing hangers in bathroom, phone that lights up by itself every 30 minutes like a flashlight, very loud refrigerator and most importantly - bed mattresses, that are obviously totally worn out plus synthetic sheets and pillows. These are the details, that makes 5 star hotel a 5 star hotel. But just because the hotel found a solution for us, without us asking anything specific - I will rate it 9. Breakfast - perfect. Dinner tasting menu in restaurant - 10/10 - that was one of the best tasting menus we ever had.

Only the things I already mentioned - there are few issues with room, that should not be in a 5 star hotel.

The property was lovely and very high class. The room was spacious and luxurious. The bathroom had a shower and a tub! And there was a separate sitting area. The staff were so friendly and helpful! We had some rental car trouble, and they helped me make phone calls and let me use the phone in the lobby when the phone in our room wouldn’t connect internationally, which really reduced my stress. The place was so relaxing!

It was a little out of the way and the food was very expensive. Although it was award winning and delicious.

Clean and quiet rooms, sound proofed well. Good complimentary selection of coffee, tea and light snacks. Friendly wonderful staff. Shower water pressure was wonderful and run very hot-had one of the best showers out of all the places we stayed on this trip. The soups were boutique and had a wonderful smell as well. Delicious dinner tasting menu (although on the expensive side for the amount and variety of dishes included) on offer from the restaurant, well thought out and inventive. Breakfast was good as well, with a selection of egg dishes, bread, and porridge.

The fire alarm went off in the middle of the night for no reason that interrupted our sleep and give us quite the scare. The staff promptly apologized in the morning, so in general we chulked it up to 'an unfortunate accident'

The location was lovely. We just spent one night there- our last on the islands- so it was our last night splurge. The tasting me dinner was superb- one of the best I have ever had, and fun to boot. It was more expensive than anticipated, especially since we did not consume alcohol, but even if I had been warned ahead of time, I still would have gone for the sheer artistry of the meal. Breakfast was very good and convenient. Did I mention our bathroom? OMG. We left early the next morning so had limited time there. Even so, the toy squirrel I traveled with (taking pictures for my granddaughter) gave Edinbane lodge two non- articulated thumbs up!

Can’t think of anything.

The place was beautiful. Decor, size, comfort, facilities, the extra touches - all amazing! Breakfast was fantastic.

We thought we were going to be able to have dinner at the in house restaurant but sadly it was not opened on Saturday night. So ended up going to a pub around the corner for very a very poor quality meal. But given the location and after a day of driving, the location doesn’t allow many alternative options.

Lovely property. Will stay there again if I'm even in the area, and would love to have dinner downstairs. Rooms were spacious, comfortable and decorated very thoughtfully. Loved the use of local art and stoneware throughout.

Breakfast was good, but woud have preferred earlier serving times. Only real complaint, which is so minor, is a lack of electrical plugs in the room. I had to unplug lamps to use an empty outlet. The narrow spital staircase going upstairs is slightly perilous too, but to be exepcted from a 1600's building. Otherwise, brilliant stay!

Very comfortable bed, great bath tub and delicious complimentary shortbread in the room, as well as a coffee pod machine. The building itself is beautiful. We had no trouble parking in the lodge car park. The breakfast was superb and made to order with lots of options and great coffee.

We thoroughly enjoyed the whole experience. The steps may be a little narrow and steep if you have mobility problems. Although staff offered to carry out bags for us.

Edinbane Lodge is an excellent small hotel, nice rooms with all the facilities you'd expect. What made our stay special was the warm welcome and attentiveness from all the staff. Thanks to Allan and Janice who were excellent.

Would like to have tried the tasting menu but kitchen closed for dinner on Monday and Tuesday. Edinbane Inn is a stone's throw away and offered good food for such a remote location.

Edinbane Lodge was very quaint looking with nice decorations and color schemes. The breakfast was delicious with a nice variety to choose from. There were teas and instant coffees, cookie packets and a kettle in the room. The staff was very friendly and helpful. It was a nice central location, especially for going around the northern peninsulas of Skye. It was a quiet place to stay unlike bustling Portree.

Our room was pretty small. We felt like the cost to stay was too expensive for the value.

Nice property and I’d rate it higher except it’s way over priced. More than twice as much as every other place we’ve stayed in Scotland and not that much nicer. Also got our beds wrong. Breakfast was good and staff is friendly.

Far too expensive for what you get.