Everything about the property was five stars! The location was great. The room was exceptionally clean. The little details were appreciated, such as bottled water and snacks in the room including robes. The breakfast was amazing with great selections and homemade banana bread to start. Rachel and Heidi were so pleasant and helpful. You can tell they enjoyed working there. We weren’t able to make the afternoon tea unfortunately this time. In the evening, there were fresh baked cookies and complementary Port and Sherry in the library. It was a nice way to wind down at the end of the day and play backgammon or chess in a lovely environment. There’s so much history in this property. We felt so welcomed and comfortable and will definitely return. We stayed in the Wild Pigeon room which was a beautiful. The bed and linens were so comfortable. We enjoyed watching movies by the fire while it rained outside. We were so happy that we found the Captain’s House Inn!!

The house and grounds are beautiful and historic. We went in the winter, mild weekend to our pleasure, the grounds were very nice, the trees especially. The other seasons must be magical. Walkable to downtown Chatham, too. We stayed in the Eliza Suite, clean cozy, great spa tub and bath salts. I will say the TV viewing set up was a bit nonsensical, only one chair had vantage point. I would get a bigger suite next time. The Complimentary breakfast is great quality and great deal! We did not get yo experience the "high tea" tiered cakes, as it wasn't offered, off season. But all day and night there are delicious home cooked scones, little muffins and pastries. The staff was also so kind and accommodating.

We came down for a couple of days for our honeymoon! Rachel greeted us and was so friendly! She led us to our room where she had champagne and chocolate covered strawberries for us!! Such a nice touch. The room was beautiful. It had a fireplace and a jacuzzi tub! The room was immaculate! The bed was extremely comfortable! We also had a back deck. It seemed lone we had the place to ourselves- the location was great ! Also , breakfast was included and delicious! We highly recommended it here ! Thank you for a wonderful stay !

The grounds are very well kept and the gardens are beautiful. Quiet gardens with only the sound of birds and the fountain. Gardens and sitting areas are around each room. The breakfast is delicious and the perfect way to start the day. Several choices and all very good. Staff is all very accommodating, welcoming and friendly. The rooms are kept very clean as well as the entire property. Fireplace also in the room.

The food was really good. We would have loved to have the option to eat there more than just for breakfast.

It’s charming, comfortable, characterful and luxurious with those extra touches that make it really special. Breakfasts are outstanding, the kitchen, waiting and housekeeping staff were an absolute joy and the bikes available on site are a great bonus. A walk to the Chatham fish market is a must and hopefully you’ll be lucky enough to see the resident seals. The Chatham Squire in town has a great ambience/vibe and the food is good and value for money. Loved it!

Nothing

Best place we’ve stayed in a long time! The staff was attentive and the food was delicious. The breakfast each morning was the best part of our day with plenty of variety. The afternoon tea and evening cookies were an added bonus. The property was meticulously maintained and we could tell the owners took pride in their establishment. Our room was cleaned daily by the staff in order for each night to be comfortable. Couldn’t recommend enough!

Absolutely nothing. Everything was perfect.

The Inn is very nice, the room was very clean and comfortable. The staff were very friendly, helpful and courteous. The breakfast was very good.

The breakfast location was extremely cold and uncomfortable. There were some maintenance issues which need to be addressed: 1. light outside the room door was inoperative; 2. The toilet float needs to be replaced, causing the water to run continuously; 3. the coffee-maker was inoperative; 4. One electrical outlet adjacent to the bed did not work.

I really want to emphasize how wonderful the innkeeper was. Rachel truly went above and beyond as the perfect host for our weekend getaway. She was incredibly responsive and welcoming, ensuring that any issues we had were addressed quickly and efficiently. The property itself is absolutely stunning, and the thoughtful extra touches—like the homemade baked goods and port in the library—made our stay feel even more special

We stayed in the beautiful Wild Pigeon room and it was so quaint. The bed was super comfy and cozy. We had our own fireplace and porch. Rachel was amazing and always there to help with information about the town and places to go. Breakfast was delicious and service and chef were wonderful. Love the history of the Captains House Inn. The grounds are well kept and more.

Everything was wonderful.

Breakfast was great. The only disappointment [minor] was that they never had the corned beef hash for the 3 days we were there. Everything else was so good that I wanted to try it. Also like the cookies left out at night for the guests.

No dislikes at all, but one suggestion...with the humidity in the area I'd strongly suggest the restaurant use salt & pepper grinders in the breakfast room. Regular salt & pepper shakers were often clogged.