111 reviews
From
$2571357 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, 44681, Ohio, United States
111 reviews
1/26
Free parking
Restaurant
Indoor swimming pool
Business center
Free wifi
Room service
Fitness center
Spa tub
Welcome to Carlisle Inn, a charming 3-star hotel located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. Just 1.8mi from the city center, this cozy hotel offers a convenient and peaceful retreat for travelers. The address of the hotel is 1357 Old Route 39, ensuring easy access to nearby attractions.
Guests of Carlisle Inn can enjoy a range of amenities including free parking, an indoor swimming pool, complimentary wifi, a spa tub, and a fitness center. The hotel also boasts a golf course for those looking to tee off during their stay, although extra charges apply. With 111 reviews, guests have praised the hotel for its friendly service and comfortable rooms, making it a popular choice for visitors to the area.
Whether you're looking to relax in the hot tub, dine in the on-site restaurant, or explore the nearby attractions, Carlisle Inn offers a convenient and welcoming stay for your travels in Sugarcreek. Book your stay now for a delightful experience in this quaint Ohio town.
After a day of exploring the area or enjoying the hotel's amenities, guests can indulge in a delicious meal at the on-site Dutch Valley Restaurant. With a family-friendly ambiance, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that caters to various tastes. From local favorites to classic comfort foods, guests can savor a delightful dining experience without having to venture far from their cozy accommodations.
For those who prefer a more active pastime, Carlisle Inn features an indoor swimming pool where guests can take a refreshing dip year-round. Whether it's a morning swim to kickstart the day or a relaxing evening soak under the stars, the pool provides a perfect way to unwind and rejuvenate during your stay. Paired with the convenience of the spa tub for added relaxation, guests can truly pamper themselves in this tranquil Ohio retreat.
Conveniently located just a short distance from Sugarcreek's city center, Carlisle Inn offers an ideal starting point to explore the area's attractions and activities. The hotel's easy access to local points of interest means guests can seamlessly venture out to discover the charm of Sugarcreek, from Amish country tours to scenic hikes in nearby parks. With a welcoming atmosphere, top-notch amenities, and a range of nearby experiences, Carlisle Inn promises an unforgettable stay for travelers seeking a delightful retreat in the heart of Ohio.
Closest airports
Akron-Canton Regional Airport
29.5miFree parking
Restaurant
Indoor swimming pool
Business center
Free wifi
Room service
Fitness center
Spa tub
Air conditioning
Hot tub
Parking On Site
Terrace
24-hour front desk
Non-smoking rooms
Patio
Elevator
Playground
Upper floors accessible by elevator
Free toiletries
Balcony
Show 4 photos
Room - 2 Queen
2 Queen Size Beds
425 sqft
Balcony
Flat-screen TV
Refrigerator
Tea/Coffee maker
+
More details
This room features air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, a refrigerator and a balcony or patio.
Show 4 photos
Deluxe, King Size
1 King Size Bed
600 sqft
Spa tub
Balcony
Microwave
Flat-screen TV
+
More details
This room features a seating area with a fireplace, a private bathroom with a spa bath and a balcony or patio.
Show 2 photos
King Room
1 King Size Bed
425 sqft
Balcony
Flat-screen TV
Refrigerator
Tea/Coffee maker
+
More details
This room features air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, a refrigerator and a balcony or patio.
Show 4 photos
Deluxe, King Size, Single Use
1 King Size Bed
1 Sofa Bed
605 sqft
Hot tub
Spa tub
Private Bathroom
Balcony
+
More details
Show 2 photos
King Room, Single Use
1 King Size Bed
1 Sofa Bed
420 sqft
Private Bathroom
Balcony
Coffee machine
Flat-screen TV
+
More details
Show 2 photos
Room - 2 Queen, Single Use
2 Queen Size Beds
420 sqft
Private Bathroom
Balcony
Coffee machine
Flat-screen TV
+
More details
Executive Suite
1 King Size Bed
x8
+
x5
More details
Suite Executive King Bed
Classic, 2 Queen Size Beds
2 Queen Size Beds
x4
+
x3
More details
Classic Two Queen Beds
Classic
1 King Size Bed
x4
+
x3
More details
Room Selected at Check in
More details
9.3
111 reviewsCategories of assessments
Cleanliness
Comfort
Location
Facilities
Staff
Value for money
WiFi quality
Breakfast
Featured reviews:
Laura
10
March 2025
The Inn was absolutely beautiful; it was spotless and extremely well kept. Our bed was in my mind "perfect" and I promise I slept better than I have in a year. I personally LOVED what I thought of as a reading room on the 1st floor with a fireplace. My husband and I utilized this space daily. (I could have stayed in there for hours) ❤️ My favorite customer service employee (I didnt get her name) was a WONDERFUL lady with the cutest little round green framed glasses. If I owned or managed this facility I would be sure she was at that desk 40 hours per week. I am a tenured Retail Manager and she gave me the EXACT experience that I want my customers to have. We had a wonderful stay at this facility.
No complaints.
Jennifer
8.2
January 2024
The executive suite is a large room with fireplace and a large whirlpool bath in the room. The property was still decorated beautifully for Christmas. It was very clean and the shared spaces were expansive. The evening snack was a nice touch.
The rooms need updated. Very bad wallpaper and decor. Many furnishings in the inn are beautiful, but our four poster bed had glue all over the top running down the sides where they had repaired them. In the bathroom there was a wet ceiling tile. When I pay for an expensive room, I expect the details to be there. The woman checking us in was a cold and like a robot, saying the same things verbatim. I have always encountered much warmer people.
Barrie
10
April 2025
The inn is conveniently located to a restaurant, bakery, gift shop, theater, and market. They are within a short walk. The free breakfast has many options, including hot items. The attendants keep the breakfast area immaculate and well stocked. In the evening snacks and beverages are set out. We also enjoyed the pool and hot tub.
Leonard
10
April 2023
We thought the beds were comfortable and it was nice to sit on the balcony and when you laid in bed you could see the outside through the balcony door. We enjoyed the 24 hours hot chocolate and coffee and the pool was opened early in the morning and it closed late at night. Like the close line in the shower that I've only seen at waterpark for drying wet clothes Restaurant within walking distance and playground in front yard
Didn't realize there was a microwave on the 2nd floor for left overs until later b/c there is none in the room. Didn't realize there was a laundry facilty b/c it's hidden behind a solid door but that's my fault for not asking.
Lydia
10
October 2023
Absolutely gorgeous!! I hope we will venture back here again. Beats any chain hotel. Set I. The beautiful Dutch Valley farm country. The Dutch Market was very nice. There's a theater gift shop and a restaurant on the grounds. Beautiful landscape. Porches and seating and fireplaces through out the Inn.
There's nothing about this beautiful place I didn't like. It's off the beaten path. Plus for us may not be for others.
Mary
8.2
September 2023
Patio to look at the country side, buffet breakfast, close to Dutch Valley buffet restaurant, Clean,Bed and sheets were exremely clean!
Buffet could of had more healthy choices like fresh fruits but you are in Amish country where the donuts and coffee are excellent! Was further out in the country and not close to relatives in Dover and New Phil. Ohio. No lists of churches. No Catholic churches nearby.
Connie
9.1
June 2024
Love the homey feeling here, and the evening snacks of popcorn and cookies. It's always so clean, too.
There's only one microwave for the entire building and it's located on the 2nd floor. Would love to have a microwave in my room, or at least on each floor. (Mainly to re-heat coffee in the morning.)
Pethrona
9.1
December 2024
Everything. We had a fantastic room with jacuzzi tub and fireplace. Staff very accommodating Great area. Market and restaurant on site. Coffee and hot chocolate 24/7
Breakfast not that great. Would have appreciated no pork meat options More fruit choices
Weyrick
10
November 2023
Outstanding Continental breakfast with exceptional coffee. We enjoyed our King Suite which included a fireplace and jetted tub. With the Bakery, Restaurant, Market, gift shop & theater you could easily not leave the premise.
Our trip was a tad early so not all of the Christmas display was put up yet. What had been done was beautiful.
Robert
9.1
September 2022
Great place to stay for a relaxing vacation in Amish country. Large rooms, excellent friendly service throughout the stay and more food than anyone really needs. All rooms have a balcony to look over the fields and enjoy a place to slow down for a while.
The bed was ok - not great. We are used to a memory foam bed, but the transition to a stiff spring bed was tough to take. Would have been nice to have a foldout couch for my youngest teen son, so he didn’t have to share with a brother.
Airports
Akron-Canton Regional Airport
29.5miAirports
Akron-Canton Regional Airport
29.5miDutch Valley Restaurant
Ambiances
Location
Availability
Free parking
Restaurant
Indoor swimming pool
Business center
Free wifi
Room service
Fitness center
Spa tub
Air conditioning
Hot tub
Parking On Site
Terrace
24-hour front desk
Non-smoking rooms
Patio
Elevator
Playground
Upper floors accessible by elevator
Free toiletries
Balcony
Accessibility
Upper floors accessible by elevator
Activities
Golf course
Bathroom
Bathrobe
Bathtub or shower
Free toiletries
Hairdryer
Private Bathroom
Shower
Spa tub
Toilet
Toilet paper
Towels
Bedroom
Alarm clock
Linens
Walk-in closet
Wardrobe or closet
Business Facilities
Business center
Fax/Photocopying
Meeting/Banquet facilities
Cleaning Services
Daily housekeeping
Entertainment & Family Services
Board games/Puzzles
Evening entertainment
Playground
Food & Drink
Restaurant
Snack bar
Front Desk Services
24-hour front desk
ATM on site
Baggage storage
Express check-in/out
General
Air conditioning
Carpeted
Convenience store on site
Elevator
Facilities for disabled guests
Heating
Non-smoking rooms
Room service
Smoke-free property
Internet
Free wifi
Kitchen
Coffee machine
Dining table
Microwave
Refrigerator
Living Area
Fireplace
Sofa
Media & Technology
Cable channels
DVD player
Flat-screen TV
Radio
Telephone
TV
Outdoors
Balcony
Outdoor furniture
Patio
Terrace
Parking
Free parking
Parking On Site
Physical distancing
Cashless payment available
Room Amenities
Clothes rack
Fan
Iron
Sofa bed
Safety & security
Carbon monoxide detector
Safe
Smoke alarms
Services
Wake-up service
Spa
Fitness center
Hot tub
Indoor swimming pool
Pets are not allowed.
WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.
The minimum age for check-in is 21
Free public parking is available on site (reservation is not needed).
Child policies
Children of all ages are welcome.
Children 13 and above will be charged as adults at this property.
To see correct prices and occupancy info, add the number and ages of children in your group to your search.
Crib and extra bed policies
No capacity for extra beds or cribs.
Cash
American Express,
Discover,
Mastercard,
Visa
This property does not accept cash.
1120 Gateway Place, Dover, 44622, Ohio, United States
6.2mi from current hotel
Excellent
129 reviews
From
5330 County Road 201, Millersburg, 44654, Ohio, United States
11.6mi from current hotel
Very Good
693 reviews
From
145 Bluebell Drive Sw, New Philadelphia, 44663, Ohio, United States
7.3mi from current hotel
Very Good
103 reviews
From
1299 West High Avenue, New Philadelphia, 44663, Ohio, United States
7.1mi from current hotel
Very Good
70 reviews
From
200 Morris Crossing Ave, Newcomerstown, 43832, Ohio, United States
15.5mi from current hotel
Very Good
41 reviews
From
161 Bluebell Dr Sw, New Philadelphia, 44663, Ohio, United States
7.2mi from current hotel
Good
190 reviews
From
111 Mccauley Drive, Uhrichsville, 44683, Ohio, United States
15.1mi from current hotel
Pleasant
108 reviews
From
1256 West High Avenue Rear, New Philadelphia, 44663, Ohio, United States
7.2mi from current hotel
Pleasant
49 reviews
From
181 Bluebell Drive South West, New Philadelphia, 44663, Ohio, United States
7.2mi from current hotel
Pleasant
187 reviews
From
Featured hotels
Featured hotels
Cities nearby
Popular cities