Breakfast room and location is wonderful, food is about standard for a hotel breakfast, staff is very attentive. Beautiful rooms and architecture, great history through out the building, photos and paintings - a real sense of being somewhere historic.

Beds had no headboard which is odd and uncomfortable. Pillows could be a little better- they were on the small side. Rooms are a little cramped but that's to be expected for this era of hotels and when it was built. Bathroom accessories did not meet the pricing of the hotel room - would expect this kind of hotel to be about $25-30 cheaper per night, it's not a 4 star and I paid 4 star prices.

Perfect location. Very pretty old hotel. The lobby and lounge are beautiful. Nice room with old hotel charm. It was a lovely visit and I hope to visit again.

Not many "hotel" amenities. An offering of bottled water somewhere would be nice, stocked in room fridge or in lobby, or even a bottle filling machine in lobby. Breakfast was basic but good. Was hoping to get the yummy muffins the reviews of Penn Lodge spoke of since the facilities are related.

We were looking for a downtown location that had most everything within walking distance and the hotel did have all that we needed. The beds were an okay size for the size of the room and age of the facility; we wanted historic, and we got that. Additional items needed were brought up quickly, service was good. The lobby was a fun place to have coffee and hang out.

The cold breakfast was very limited but good, the location of the swimming pool, and optional hot breakfast was located in another lodge about a block away, not a real big deal just different but they worked together and so all that was listed was offered. The only thing missing for us was a coffee maker in the room, but they provided coffee and tea starting at 6 AM so that worked well too.

The quaintness of the hotel. Very interesting. Also, the French onion soup in the lounge was excellent.

Ordered a shrimp quesadilla in the lounge, and it was so salty I couldn't eat it. It's put me off quesadillas for the foreseeable future. I also wish there was a bit more variety at breakfast. For four days, it was scrambled eggs and sausage. It was good the first two days, but got tiring.

Friendly and helpful staff. Great lobby and dining areas. Too bad lounge was closed. Breakfast was good but could have used more variety day to day.

Didn’t expect small size of room (305), furnishings were comfortable, a little worn but clean and serviceable. Could use more shelving in bathroom and a lounge type chair in room. A little disappointed that room was not styled as in 1930-40s similar to downstairs.

Location at the heart of Wellsboro and free parking Friendly staff Clean rooms

The floor was tilted, and thus the bed and everything else was askew. The floor was squeaky. The bed wasn't very comfortable. The room hasn't been renovated in decades. It was hard to control the temperature in the room. Breakfast was underwhelming. The room was small. There was no smart TV in the room, just cable TV.

This is a historic hotel - beautifully maintained, the history shared throughout the building. It does not have the newness of a more modern hotel room; it was charming, like a trip back in time and we really enjoyed our stay. The staff was welcoming, breakfast the next morning was good, the location was excellent (lots of places to eat and shop in walking distance), and the rooms were clean. The restaurant and lounge onsite were really good as well. If you are looking for a unique experience and appreciate the history, you will love this place!

Nothing

We will stay at Pennwells whenever in town. Great, friendly and helpful staff. Cannot say enough about the genuine warmth and willingness to help from all staff I met. Met fun and interesting people in the lobby and bar.

Maybe a little modernization in the bathroom. Faucets and showerheads, there was no plug in the bathtub for my wife to take a bath after a long day outdoors.

Great location and the woman at the front desk was very helpful - recommended a great restaurant the second night - had a wonderful dinner at the Lounge in hotel the first night. Spent 4th of July weekend cycling the Pine Creek Rail Trail, which is only 7-8 mile drive from downtown Wellsboro, Pa. Great breakfast - gentleman serving breakfast was pleasant and very helpful. Staff as a whole were wonderful.

Just like many old hotels, the rooms were tiny.

Penn Wells is an old landmark hotel, and the staff work hard to keep it functioning as it should. All the staff were attentive and personable. We had no problems at all to report, but friends we were traveling with did have some minor issues in the room that were addressed immediately.

There is a LOT of truck traffic through this small town, so it is very noisy. This is not under the control of the hotel, of course.