It’s a really lovely place. Rooms are lovely. Comfortable bed and staff nice. Food is lovely . Scrambled egg at breakfast was really good. And the flat iron steak was so tender. The cheese Stilton sauce was really good. The rooms were very clean and beautifully done. And the view would have been lovely but it wasn’t a great day weather wise for that. Couldn’t really see view from our room because of a hedge in the way. But some other rooms had a view so if you want a view from your window just ask for a view.

The hedge that was outside the window. And staff were very nice but a bit slow on service. Don’t think there we’re enough staff by looks of it.

Huge bathroom with lovely soaps and creams Very Comfortable big bed Location of the property Super meal Quiet, even though we were right above the public bar

Very little! But, the curtains were not fixed fully, and the outside light shone in The coffee machine was too complicated- simple instructions needed! The grouting around the outside of the shower was old and needs refreshing. There was no bath or shower mat so the floor got wet - and there were no anti slip mats inside the shower or bath either.

This is a lovely place to stay. Looking over a lovely garden and views each room or chalet. Really done out well are the chalets . Lovely big pub with soft seating areas for guests to chill. And a separate restaurant area. Food was lovely and they made a special effort because it was our wedding anniversary and brought us out a plate with happy anniversary in chocolate writing and some little brownie s and a glass of champagne each. Couldn’t fault that. The room was so nice. Big bath and shower and bed so comfortable. Seating area that looked over the beautiful garden and view. And patio door that opened up onto your own terrace. Breakfast was also nice. But would have preferred to go up to a breakfast cereal station to get juice and yogurt and cereal instead of having to ask waitress for juice. No mention of cereal.

Probably attention to detail in clearing tables. Without people having to go up to ask for previous people’s plates and glasses and cups to be cleared after a while after sitting there. It is on the tad of expensive side and the price you pay you should get your breakfast including in the price. I do a lot and as you know reviews and stay in a lot of hotels all over the country. And this one is one of the more expensive ones. Even though we have stayed in top notch places in the Coxwold and Windsor and London.

We recently stayed here for two nights, just to get away from home for a short break. It's a 45-minute drive from Redcar or Saltburn, where we like to park south of Redcar and walk the 3-4 miles down the beach to Salburn, eat fish n chips and walk back. Also, it's just a 15-minute train ride into York. The pub is located in a quiet rural hamlet about 5-6 minutes drive from Thirsk. The pub is first class and very comfortable with burning log fires etc. The restaurant is also first class but not particularly costly. The dinner menu is £19 for two courses and £25 for three. The food is high quality "Gastro Pub" style and is all homemade. Eating there for breakfast and dinner is a nice treat that doesn't break the bank. The 8 or 9 garden rooms are fabulous. They are located in a self-contained block across a super garden across from the pub. There was no noise from the pub, and our room was perfectly insulated from the room next door. Again, first class room for the money. Comfy bed, sitting area with a sofa and two chairs and patio door looking onto the gardens. We have stayed here once before, and we were in one of the two rooms above the pub bar. I couldn't rate those rooms as highly because, as you would expect in an old pub, they were somewhat noisy from the pub's activities below. Still, those rooms are much better than similar rooms we have stayed in in the past. I can highly recommend a stay here, particularly in a garden view room. We'll be back in a couple of months for sure.

When staying in a garden-view room, there is nothing not to like.

Loved the ambience of the Carpenters Arm from the moment of our arrival, with the friendly staff the quality of the room, and the first drink around the open fire after a chilly day visiting Castle Howard at Christmas. Dinner was excellent and the menu was varied enough for both of us to have choices to make. The rooms were spacious well appointed with a lounge area to relax, and dog friendly. In the morning sunlight the courtyard rooms lead onto a grassy green with a fence located at the top of the escarpment offering long distance views to the west over Thirsk. A short walk to the main building offered up a lovely cooked breakfast, and the alternative choices on offer in the restaurant, with a view.

Only struggle was to find the roof blind control in the corner of a wall of room 4, not easy to see until in bed. Not much to let the side down, in a very well appointed hostelry. Perfect retreat for a wintery evening.

Nice location, lovely room. Staff friendly and helpful. We'd only come across the place as we had decided to break our journey home, and the original booking at another venue fell through...so they suggested this venue as an alternative. Turned out to be the better of the two!

Location threw the SatNav into a panic...it took us on an 18 mile detour to get to the Carpenters Arms from the centre of Thirsk!

Staff were fantastic, very helpful and always had a smile on their face. Food was wonderful. We are both nights and had breakfast both days and found we had plenty of choice. The beetroot starter was one of the best starters I’ve had!

We were in a upstairs room. It could do with a refresh, it’s looking a bit tired and worn. A bit of a deeper clean would be good; like high cobwebs, curtain needed sewn, inside shower could do with a deep clean. Small things but to me they make a difference. Won’t put us off going back, we had a great weekend.

This little pub totally blew me away. I booked as was in area for work at 5 pm on booking .com.was cheaper than premier inns and other hotels. Food in the restaurant was absolutely delicious.I had pie mash and vegetables and was thoroughly amazing food. Sticky toffee pudding was fantastic too. The room was very comfortable, very comfortable mattress and a nespresso machine. Boiling hot power shower and lovely views from my window. Will definitely be coming back and bringing my wife next time.

Everything was bloody brilliant, cannot fault it.

Liked the food and the people the surroundings .

The heating in the room was left on could not turn it off so had to open windows during the night and also the cleanliness of the bathroom could do to be looked at i.e. skirting boards and behind the sink and the shower .

A great place to stay in the heart of Yorkshire sightseeing - close to Rivaulx Abbey, Hemsley Castle and easy distance of Fountains Abbey. Staff were friendly, our room had all amenities as described including little bottles of fresh milk in fridge so we could make tea. Dinner and breakfast were delicious and generous portions.