Location is fantastic and I loved the vintage feel to the hotel. It's kept well and although the carpet could be newer... the rest of the furniture was great. I also liked that they have their own garage (albeit paid but not a bad fee for full day use).

Only thing that comes to mind is that when I walked into the hotel en route towards the reception, there was one older gentleman sitting behind one of the smaller desks across the reception (I assume he's an attendant/porter) and he was just deadpan staring at me. I greeted him as an acknowledgement and he just sat there looking at me with no response so that was a bit awkward and unwelcoming as I felt like I was walking through the Twilight Zone. Other than that -- everything else was great and as described. The hotel does have a dress code but nothing crazy and is definitely doable.

The architecture of the building is amazing. It has an old stately feeling to it from the moment you walk into the lobby…and I mean “old” in the best possible way. There is nothing cheap or plastic looking about this place. Yes, it has flat panel tvs, WiFi access, and card swipe locks on the doors, but everything about this place screams historic, and that makes it wonderfully different from other places in the area. And if you like to work out…WOW! For $15 extra per room (not per person), you can take advantage of their phenomenal work out facilities. This isn’t a normal one room crammed with crappy equipment hotel gym. THIS is any kind of workout you can imagine they have it available hotel gym, including an indoor swimming pool, full size basketball court, weight room, machine room, bike room, walking/running track, pickleball court, etc. It truly is an Athletic Club. We were there for a volleyball tournament at the Americas Arena, and it was easily within walking distance (even in February with snow on the ground). We asked if they could do lunch for our volleyball team at Jack Buck’s restaurant on the bottom floor of the hotel. Not only did they say YES, but they asked for the team colors and name and suggested a shortened menu to limit the options to make it easier on the parents and girls (which it definitely did!)…then they printed special keepsake menus and matched the napkins to our team colors (as close as they could come). It was such a special experience for the girls and for the parents! Every member of their staff from the front desk people to the restaurant staff to the housekeeping staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient.

I would have loved a little more counter space (or ANY counter space for that matter) in the bathroom. A little more water pressure would be nice, too.

The entire ordeal, renting the room through Booking.Com, finding the place, checking in with the VERY helpful staff members, buying a couple high dollar cigars from the same wonderful lady, and then having to spend a good 20min picking my jaw off the floor when I saw the Billiards Room, Leather clad Reading Room, and then my own room, which was more comfortable than I've ever had the joy of sleeping in. The entire experience was not just simply "acceptable", it was the standard to which every other hotel should base themselves on!

Please see above.

I love the location and the exquisite architecture and art collection. Since it’s a private club I got to feel like royalty being there. A very unique experience. The restaurants were wonderful too. And parking garage is so convenient. From the front door to the Arch Park and Eads Bridge is one block. An evening walk on the bridge to view the city was magnificent!

The dress code is not my style. But they worked with me! I didn’t like from parking garage you have to enter the back door. But hey, travel clothes don’t meet the front door image. Nothing else I didn’t like. I love love it and hope to return again.

Great reception, hotel accomodated my friends arriving a little sooner than my family did. They spoke like they were well received despite not having a room in their name. That is appreciated. No frills checkout. Enjoyed the Jack Buck Grille for a couple of drinks following the Battlehawks game.

Our fault for not really checking on and using the other amenities on other floors of the MAC Hotel. It is a different setup than other hotels were the amenities are not grouped together near the reception area on the ground floor: food/drink, exercise, pool. Meaning if a tour of the MAC was offered, we might have accepted. An opportunity to show off the history of the MAC while familiarizing guests in person with where the highlights are.

This was a fun experience and very different from most hotels. It's a heritage listed building that used to be a gentlemen's sports club. It's a gorgeous building with great sports facilities. Certainly the first time I have stayed in hotel with a basketball court (with a Guinness world record attached). The sports facilities are extra but exceptional value and a great pool. The staff were lovely, especially the staff in the restaurants.

Real coffee (like a latte). I know it's America but it would have been great to have somewhere on site for a coffee. More hours when the cafe/restaurant was open. Not being able to check in till 4pm.

The whole bldg is historic, and the decor very masculine, wood walls and leather chairs. The two restaurants were excellent. We were in St Louis for a concert, to our surprise upon arrival, there was a complimentary shuttle to the venue . Upon returning, the bar stayed open for an extra hour or so for a final night cap. Could not have been a more perfect evening .

Paying for parking is never a good thing, but it was the most reasonable here. The actual rooms don’t quite match the upscale feel of the rest of the hotel, but new carpet & paint could fix that, it’s old but very clean, and the bed was very comfortable .

The gentleman (maitre d)at the dining room was very kind and helpful. I just returned from Singapore and had spent 19 hours flying, and jet lag was kicking in. He helped me get a hamburger and beer and let me take it to my room to eat. I could have hugged him, and I'm sorry I didn't tip him. He deserves that-a-boy pat on the back.

Free shuttle to/fr cardinals games: 1st run starts 1 hour before(although it’s an easy walk)There is a microwave on the 8th floor in the room with the ice machine & snack & drink vending machines. Interesting old historic place: a pool table room & a reading room with recliners, books & a piano(10th floor)..check out all the other floors too(a full size basketball court on 5!)

My room didn’t look as renovated/polished as the pics on booking but it was only for 1 night & the price was great! & the AC & ceiling fan worked great & bathroom was super clean!

This is a heritage sight turned into a hotel and events venue. It has a classic vibe and a very good value for money. Facilities are good except there seem to be no breakfast (unless you request it from the kitchen at a cost?). The area is nice, just a short walk away from the Gateway Arch and downtown with a tram station a block away to reach out other areas like the Forest Park, a pleasant green place in the mould of Central Park NY. There are a few shops towards the front of the hotel including a grocery store, a patisseries and a cafe

Did not dislike anything but a breakfast will make it a perfect place to stay in the middle of Saint Louise. Oh watch out for the raised floor of the bathroom! (you drop a step when coming back to bed :))