/
9.4

176 reviews

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

251 County Road 939, Summerland Key, 33042, Florida, United States

Choose dates to view prices

Restaurant

Private beach area

Outdoor swimming pool

Free Private Parking

Free wifi

Streaming service (like Netflix)

Air conditioning

Beach

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort is a 2-star hotel in Summerland Key, United States, Florida. The address is 251 County Road 939, and the property sits about 4.8mi from the city center. It’s a traveler-friendly option with straightforward access to local sights.

Amenities on offer include free Wi-Fi, air conditioning, private parking, and an outdoor swimming pool, with a private beach area available free of charge. On-site facilities also include a restaurant, a streaming service (like Netflix), kitchenette with kitchenware, a balcony with a view, and a sun deck, plus elevator access and non-smoking rooms. Free perks also cover beach chairs/loungers, parking on site, and live music performances. Some services incur extra charges, such as pet-friendly arrangements, snorkeling, water sports facilities on site, and the on-site bar.

The property has 176 reviews and carries a 2-star rating.

Sun, sea, and island charm come together for an easygoing Keys stay. The outdoor pool is all-season, heated, and shallow-ended with a view, making it a pleasant splash spot for any time of day. A private beach area is available free of charge, and beach chairs and loungers are provided to soak up the sun. On-site parking keeps the day trips rolling without a hitch.

Refuel at Cafe at Sugarloaf Key Resort, the on-site American cuisine restaurant, and enjoy entertainment options like a streaming service for downtime. Handy creature comforts include a kitchenette with kitchenware, a balcony with a view, and a sun deck, plus elevator access and non-smoking rooms to suit different travel needs.

Pet lovers can request accommodation for their furry friends, with charges potentially applying. Payment is accepted via Discover, Mastercard, American Express, and Visa, while cash is not accepted. The property has 176 reviews and carries a 2-star rating, offering a straightforward, traveler-friendly experience. Free perks include beach chairs/loungers, parking on site, and live music performances, while some services—such as pet-friendly arrangements, snorkeling, water sports facilities on site, and the on-site bar—may incur extra charges.

Closest airports

Key West International Airport

16.7mi

Most popular amenities

Restaurant

Private beach area

Outdoor swimming pool

Free Private Parking

Free wifi

Streaming service (like Netflix)

Air conditioning

Beach

Sun deck

Parking On Site

Non-smoking rooms

Live music/Performance

Kitchenware

Kitchenette

Wheelchair accessible

Beach chairs/Loungers

Elevator

Free toiletries

Balcony

View

Upper floors accessible by elevator

Rooms

Show 12 photos

Deluxe Suite

1 Queen Size Bed

Kitchen

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

+

More details

Show 15 photos

Suite, Sea View

Kitchen

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

+

More details

Show 13 photos

Family Suite

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

Flat-screen TV

+

More details

Show 13 photos

Suite

Kitchen

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

+

More details

Show 10 photos

Suite, Balcony

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

Flat-screen TV

+

More details

Show 13 photos

Superior Suite, Sea View

Kitchenette

Balcony

Microwave

Flat-screen TV

+

More details

Guest reviews

9.4

176 reviews

Categories of assessments

Cleanliness

Comfort

Location

Facilities

Staff

Value for money

WiFi quality

Featured reviews:

🇺🇸

Jennifer

8.2

June 2025

This was our first time back since being rebuilt. We stated at the motel and brought our boat. All the staff we're very nice, except the blonde woman at check-in was very short with me and then she was rude to our friends when they arrived later that day. She kinda set a bad tone at the start, but we didn't see her again, and v everyone else was very nice. The location was great. Grounds were beautiful and very well maintained. The marina was nice, and the staff there went above and beyond to help us. Having the boat ramp right there made it so convenient. Our only complaint would be that the mattresses in our room were very flimsy and uncomfortable and we didn't sleep well. But the people we were with stayed in another room and said theirs was fine. All in all, it was a great trip!

Mattresses

🇺🇸

June

10

March 2025

This is an exceptional facility, beautifully landscaped and well-appointed. The suite was roomy, comfortable, and quiet. My room was on the third floor of the North Hotel building. I had a marvelous sunrise view and enjoyed breakfast on my balcony every morning. Evening entertainment in the pub on Saturday night was Howard Livingston and Mile Marker 24. It was great—Jimmy Buffet-style music and everyone was dancing. I would stay here again in a heartbeat.

The bedroom should have a room-darkening window covering. The window faces the outdoor walkway, which is brightly lit. This is great if you come in late at night but not so much if you are sensitive to light. I wore an eye mask, which worked well, but the room should be dark. Also, the EXIT light over the door is huge and bright at night, plus the door is frosted glass, which lets in a lot of light from the walkway. If someone tries to sleep on the sofa bed, this light would shine in their eyes. As far as I know, none of the suites offer a king-size bed. This was not a problem for me by myself, but couples who are used to staying in a facility of this quality would expect a king-size bed.

🇺🇸

Heather

10

March 2025

Beautiful property, our second visit to this location. Quickly becoming a family favorite! Love the location, a short drive to key west or up to Bahia Honda state park. Pool and hot tub are amazing and well-kept grounds! The staff from the bait and rental shop went above and beyond to keep everything amazing! The outdoor balcony for breakfast was a great way to wake up!

The cook top could be a bit bigger if you plan to use it. We cooked breakfast and dinner, so it was a little harder to navigate a meal. Or smaller pans, we made it work, no worries, just small obstacles. 😉

🇺🇸

Amy

10

March 2025

The property was laid out beautifully with a variety of landscaping. Everything was very clean and looked well-kept! The staff were wonderful and the food was very fresh and good! We appreciated every aspect of the KOA and honestly couldn’t find anything we would have done differently in terms of the amenities or facilities!

It is hard to find anything not to like. The only thing my husband and I both noted were that the beds were not the most comfortable, rather firm, but that is all.

🇨🇦

Carmen

9.1

March 2025

Location was great- about 30 minutes from Key West. Easy access off the highway. The property is immaculate! Very clean, including the hotel room we stayed in. The kitchen was very well appointed and there were full-size washer and dryer in unit. Also a huge, private balcony to watch the sunrise. The pool area makes you feel like you’re in a high-end resort and is sheltered from the wind with lush landscaping.

The mattress felt tired and a little saggy, and the pillows were too firm for my liking.

🇺🇸

Kirk

9.1

February 2025

Property was very clean and looked brand new. So nice to have a kitchen and a private bedroom when traveling with kids. We paid a little extra at the site for a room upgrade and had a view of the water and bunk beds for kids so they didn’t have to sleep on a pull out couch (but that looked nice too!) Beautiful pool and water play area.

Only tricky part was tight parking for a larger car/truck. It would also be great to have room numbers on where to park, but that wasn’t a problem once we figured it out.

🇺🇸

Joan

9.1

November 2024

The property has so much to do. The beach area is fun for the kids with a water park. The pool is very clean and the hot tub was outstanding. We rented a kayak there and had a great time in the mangroves. Our unit was very nice and the balcony with a water view was enjoyable.

We struggled with the music being on all day at the pool. It was loud in our room at times. The live bands were very loud in the hotel area. We prefer a place with more quiet areas .

🇺🇸

Roger

10

March 2025

Hotel was excellent. Location was about 30 minutes outside of Key West. Hotel is actually on a KOA campground but you would never know once inside. One of the nicest and cleanest hotels we have ever stayed at. I would definitely recommend this hotel to anyone. And I will definitely stay here again when we come back to Key West.

The only issue we had was the parking spots for the hotel was very small. But other than that every thing else was great.

🇺🇸

Karin

10

February 2025

Location was perfect, 30 minutes from the airport and the busyness of Key West. There is a private beach and marina on site. The staff was extremely friendly. I especially loved that the room was actually an efficiency with refrigerator, dishwasher, washer, dryer and range top.

If I had to pick something, the parking spaces under the hotel were a little narrow. But otherwise, this place was perfect for our much needed vacation.

🇺🇸

Leslie

10

June 2025

Location was ideal. Only 20 minutes away from the hustle and bustle of Key West. Beautiful landscaping, quiet, immaculate, amazing breezy views. Enjoyed the live music and large pool. Rooms were large, clean, modern and comfortable. Kitchenette was very well equipped. There wasn’t a thing that I looked for that wasn’t supplied.

Only complaint was that the pool water was too warm. Need to add chillers.

Points of Interest Around Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Airports

Key West International Airport

16.7mi

Restaurants

Cafe at Sugarloaf Key Resort

Cuisines

  • American

Pools

Location

  • Outdoor

Features

  • Heated
  • Shallow end
  • With view

Age restrictions

  • Adults only

Availability

  • All season

Amenities of Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Restaurant

Private beach area

Outdoor swimming pool

Free Private Parking

Free wifi

Streaming service (like Netflix)

Air conditioning

Beach

Sun deck

Parking On Site

Non-smoking rooms

Live music/Performance

Kitchenware

Kitchenette

Wheelchair accessible

Beach chairs/Loungers

Elevator

Free toiletries

Balcony

View

Upper floors accessible by elevator

Stay rules - Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

  • Check-in / Check-out

  • Pets

  • Internet

  • Age restrictions

  • Curfew

  • Parking

  • Children and beds

  • Cards accepted at this property