The leisure facilities are great - big swimming pool, a steam room and a sauna. Room was cosy and big enough. Multiple restaurants and bars across the property. The staff was very caring and polite. We came for a wedding anniversary and we got offered a free drinks. Thanks again! We ate at the brasserie and the food was good. Price are reasonable for Edinburgh. You can come by bus from city centre, making it a great staycation for a special weekend

The bar near the brasserie was very cold. Wonder if you could put more heaters on.

Lovely location and the original building is spectacular. Staff were friendly and helpful. Special mention to Neil who went the extra mile to help with stay and providing information.

The pool was very busy and so didn't use . No jacuzzi despite this being advertised. Few faults with room, extractor not working in bathroom, bulb not working, no sockets by beds and USB charger not working by bed.

Beautiful hotel and location, set in lovely woodlands, very well kept grounds with lovely walks .

We booked and were given a room in another wing away from the old main building which we were expecting to stay in , but we booked on booking.com so probably our fault. Id not say we dislike anything, this place is quality.

Staff as always were brilliant. Friendly and helpful throughout. Breakfast was good and the restaurant for dinner was excellent. Lovely tasty food well prepared and served. Room lovely and comfortable.

The only issue we had was we were in a room at the back of the hotel overlooking a garden. There was a bird in there with a couple of young ones (looked like oystercatchers) that made a lot of noise from very early in the morning and actually well after it turned dark. Meant we had disturbed sleep both nights. If anyone gets a room there might be worth checking if they're still there!

The location of the hotel is amazing, it is sourended with beautiful greenery, lake, courts, 10 mins by car from city center, 10 mins by car from airport.

Hotel is very busy. In the room you can hear everything from all other rooms, talking, literaly each world, snoring, coughing, etc.... To have breakfast is like a quest, during 10 days of our stay we did not wait in the que once when we came for breakfast at 7 am, otherwise during all other 10 days when we came at 8 am we had to que for 20-40 mins, then 20 mins time to wait for eggs or porridge. You can not spend 1-1.5 hr for breakfast even on the holiday.

Dalmahoy is a beautiful tranquil retreat from busy Edinburgh. However, it is only approx. 20 mins away. from Edinburgh making it a fantastic accommodation option, particularly if you prefer the peace of the countryside. We took a taxi into Edinburgh from Dalmahoy. This was easily arranged by the hotel and was not expensive. Our room was very comfortable and clean. Breakfast had both a la carte and buffet options, with a large assortment for all tastes. We dined at the Pentland restaurant. The food and service were exceptional!! Car parking is available and easy to access. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Dalmahoy and thank you to all the lovely, dedicated staff who made this so enjoyable.

Sometimes a little difficult to navigate the hotel.

The breakfast was the best breakfast we had while on our trip to Scotland, and we had stayed at 4 different locations. Additionally, the service was impeccable, and the surrounding area was beautiful. The public transit was only a ~10 minute walk from the hotel.

The only issue we had during our stay was the wifi. Since we were traveling internationally, we had limited access to data, and wifi was important. It may have been due to staying on the lower level, but wifi consistently disconnected, and when connected hardly allowed for any access whatsoever.

A beautiful hotel with stunning views and spacious rooms. There’s a great playground for kids, and we really enjoyed watching the local wildlife — we even spotted two deer roaming the golf course! The fitness center is well-equipped, and the indoor swimming pool was a nice bonus.

The windows in our room couldn't be fully opened, and the room was quite hot. When we asked the reception about it, they said there’s a law that prevents them from allowing windows to open fully. However, we noticed that windows in other rooms were fully open, which was confusing and disappointing. Also, the way to the rooms was very confusing — the layout felt like a maze, making it difficult to find our way around.

Very clean and beautiful hotel

- Mattresses too soft. - Breakfast was not good and also the coffee machines, very bad quality hot drinks. - Restaurants need improvement: Food is not good, it is a shame that such a nice hotel has only 2,7 ​​and 3 star reviews in restaurants. We could have eaten there but we didn't and ended up spending in other restaurants, we were 7 people and stayed for 4 nights, so it is a huge waste of money for the hotel. I strongly recommend you to invest in good and qualified chefs to improve the ratings of the restaurants.

Location and the prices of food and drink where very reasonable

The temperature of the public area where quite cold. Also it lacked little bit of atmospher, entertainment of some kind would have been nice, we often go away at this time of year and most hotels have something like a pianist, or someone pksyinf Scottish music etc, this would have been nice.