The Bed, especially the pillows, was extremely comfy. The Room itself was top notch, loved the radio and recorder player in the room. The Amenities, which was housed in a little doll house, was an excellent and thoughtful idea. The breakfast was outstanding, one of the best meals in York we had. The Pantry is such a unique idea. The WiFi was strong even in the far reaches of the hotel. The staff was friendly and approachable, especially the lady in the morning/early afternoon who welcoming, understanding and always had a positive attitude.

The Pantry needed some other drinks perhaps a small bottle of water. Our room had a little mold in the shower near the hair products, Plug in the bath, had hair tied around it from previous guest- a little watch out and just a minor blimp in an otherwise 5* stay.

We had a very nice experience staying here. The hotel's location is in close proximity to the center of town. An easy walk. They also have a gated parking lot if you have a car. The staff was kind and the room was charming. Who else offers a portable turntable in your room with vinyl records at your disposal? What a fun perk! They have two lovely rooms where one can sit and enjoy afternoon tea or a cocktail. The adjoining restaurant, Pearly Cow, was also a nice experience. Warm cozy ambience in the evening and good food and drinks. I would definitely return and do recommend!

No complaints really.

Location, just out of walled city, convenient to walk in to city or car trips out of city. Bedroom well appointed and comfortable bed. Room could have been a tadge too small bigger. Staff very friendly and helpful. (Free) pantry always well stocked. Lovely breakfast.

Car parking a bit expensive, but that is York! A warning about number of stairs should be made. A bit tough for people with mobility problems. Too many pre visit “looking forward to seeing you” emails. I missed an important message about location of car park, which would have saved about 45 mins of going up and down the main road through a 4 way road restriction!

We loved our stay at No1 York Guest House. We had our room upgraded and the hotel was dog friendly. The staff were all lovely, helpful and welcoming. We had dinner in our room which was excellent and we also had breakfast in our room which was great. Lovely luxurious deep bath in the bathroom! The bed was huge and comfortable! The room was large and clean. The dollshouse was a lovely touch with teas/coffees/milk etc. Our room had a DAB radio which was on when we arrived and even a record player, aswell as a TV with apps. The hotel is about a 10minute walk into city centre. We also found a very handy field to exercise our dog in just 2 minutes up the road. The neighbourhood felt very safe and it was clean. Also able to park at the property for charge. We also LOVED the pantry, complimentary sweets/crisps/fruit and soft drinks!

Free parking would have been great but understand spaces are limited and still it was cheaper than parking in the city.

We had a lovely welcome from the person on reception who took us up to the room and explained where everything was. Our dog was made to feel very welcome with a bed, treats and water bowl. The room was a good temperature even on a hot day as the air conditioning worked well. The bed was very comfortable and we had a lovely big bathroom. You could hear the sound of the road outside faintly but we didn’t mind it and it’s to be expected when the hotel is on a main road. The location for walking into the centre of York was great.

The EV car chargers were not working.

I had the full English breakfast & the two large sausages were particularly delicious! The two rashers of bacon were beautifully cooked and I also had two absolutely perfect poached eggs. My drink of choice was coffee and I enjoyed two cups. from the cafetière.

I requested some toast and was rather disappointed to find that I was charged extra for two slices of toast to accompany my cooked breakfast! However, it was beautifully cooked but perhaps it could be made a little more clear what is NOT included in the cooked breakfast for £20.

There were so many thoughtful details here, and the rooms were just adorable. I can’t think of a single thing we didn’t like. The location was perfect for an easy walk to city center and a short ride to the train station,staff was super friendly and kind, the room was spacious and well-appointed (loved the inclusion of some records and a player in our room!), there were plenty of easily accessible outlets for two travelers, and the bath amenities were wonderful. My only regret is that we couldn’t stay longer.

That I don’t live there permanently 🤣

Great location, easy to walk everywhere. Great staff. Welcoming and helpful. Fun/unusual vibe with some delightful and quirky aspects. (Old record players in the room!) The generous “pantry” was really a welcome treat when you just wanted a quick snack—crisps/soda/cake—to tide you over. Easy and quick. And if you did want to linger over treats instead of sightseeing, both the bar and the tea room looked fantastic though we did not use either. Also appreciated this was an easy walk from the train station.

It’s a bit worn here and there.

Beautiful quirky hotel and friendly efficient staff. Delicious seasonal top quality food and drinks on offer at the hotel. Very convenient location with a car park, close to all the major attractions of York City centre. We didn't use the Spa, although have heard great reviews.

Our cosy double was certainly cosy with no air con, but we were lucky with a good breeze coming through the open windows during very hot weather. The communal pantry is a nice touch for snacks, but should provide fresh milk over anything.

Gorgeous victorian themed hotel. Stayed 4 nights to celebrate my 50th and wanted somewhere special that was dog friendly. Just me and the dog. The whole trip was one of the best I have been on but the hotel just added to that. Staff were very friendly and loved Oscar who had all the guests enamered with him also as he's just happy to sit quietly and relax. Room I wouldn't quite say is to my taste, but lovely big and comfortable 4 poster and large room. I was at the back so very quiet at night also. Loved the free pantry in the corridor lots of snacks and drinks. Had two nights in the pearly cow. Pan fried chicken 1st night was gorgeous came on a bed of peas with pancetta and sauce. I don't like peas much but ate the whole lot it was so tasty as was the chicken and normally chicken is quite bland. Fillet steak second time and best steak had in long time. First night was allowed dog in main area as wasn't busy. Second time was in lounge but others had dogs as well so wasn't in there alone. Dogs allowed in main restaurant for breakfast which again was lovely food. Nice relaxing bar area with its quirky train that runs round the room, and also lounge as mentioned with good cocktails and recommend the pino-noir.. Very close to centre so short stroll to other restaurants etc. Walk out the back of hotel and again its a short stroll to river walks where you can walk miles. Didn't use the spa area but looked very nice. Would I stay there again? Without a doubt.

Nothing not to like. As feedback though please get some decent ironing boards they are awful might as well have done it on floor. The bedroom windows in room 10 could do with opening a few more inches.