Staying at the Edgartown Inn is like walking into the pages of a refined New England design magazine — but with soul, warmth, and genuine kindness woven into every detail. The interiors are a perfect blend of coastal elegance and curated simplicity, each room bathed in light and beauty. But what truly sets this place apart are the thoughtful touches and extraordinary hospitality. Mornings begin with a divine breakfast: artisan Nada Bread bursting with berries, homemade cranberry juice, creamy coconut chia seed pudding, perfectly cooked eggs — all served with care and generosity. Fresh water, rich coffee, and the unforgettable Championship cookies are always within reach. Beyond the aesthetics and comfort, it’s the team’s sincere attention that makes the experience unforgettable. Whether it’s offering insider tips on the best hidden corners of Martha’s Vineyard, recommending the perfect sunset spot, or simply sharing a smile, there’s a constant sense of care and presence. It’s more than a stay — it’s a heartfelt invitation to feel at home, embraced by beauty and kindness.

My stay at The Edgartown Inn was nothing short of a magical escape, a dream come true on the enchanting island of Martha’s Vineyard, a place I had longed to discover for years. And it truly lived up to every expectation – and beyond. The Edgartown Inn is the very definition of refined simplicity: elegant without excess, effortlessly tasteful, welcoming yet serene. Perfectly located, it radiates the charm of those coastal interiors you find in the most beautiful design magazines, with that special atmosphere, cosy, curated, and deeply comforting. Everything was just right: the exceptional breakfasts, understated yet incredibly classy; the genuine kindness of the staff – and most especially Neusa, whose grace, care, and professionalism made the experience unforgettable. This is a place that ticks every box: elegance, serenity, balance, and sophistication. A true haven of peace, exactly how you imagine New England at its finest. I recommend it a thousand times over, and I’ll return with my eyes closed.

Nothing

We loved the design of the property. The outdoor spaces are so cozy and lovely. The bedding is super comfortable. The staff was extremely friendly and you can tell they truly care about the Inn that they work at and making sure everyone has a lovely relaxing time. We also loved the location, the inn is super central. It is so nice to be so close to many restaurants, shops, the harbor, and the lighthouse.

Nothing - we liked everything!

Our experience at the Edgartown Inn was fantastic from start to finish. The staff is incredibly warm, helpful and truly made us feel valued as guests from the moment we arrived. The daily breakfast options were simple, but delicious. The inn was recently renovated and looks fantastic. Our room was large and comfortable and a great value for summertime on the Vineyard. The inn is located just a few minutes walk from the ferry drop off if you take a ferry in from the Cape and is the perfect location for quick walks to the best shopping and restaurants in the town.

The location in Edgartown was excellent and almost in the canter of town. The front porch was superb and offered a view of the harbor and overlooked N. Water St. which offered a partial view of the town.

The price was uncomfortably high and the hotel didn't seem to offer any midweek/senior discounts although I believe there were empty rooms during my midweek stay.

The property was in an excellent location and was extremely welcoming. We arrived early but not a problem at all, we were treated to some warm chocolate cookies just out the oven. A very restful place to stay and everything in Edgartown is within walking distance. Good tips on where to visit and dine.

Only issue I had was the cost of parking, although I imagine in high season parking is a nightmare but not at the end of the season in October.

The Edgartown Inn is centrally located and close to everything you could want in town. The staff (Neusa) went out of their way to make my birthday weekend special by upgrading us to a larger room with an expansive porch. Continental breakfast was provided with yummy offerings such as overnight oats, homemade muffins and tasty juices. If we go back to Martha's Vineyard, we will definitely stay at the Edgartown Inn again!

The property is incredibly centrally located and you can walk to all the shops and restaurants within a few minutes. It's super cute, very clean, friendly staff, and a nice little outdoor common area to have a glass of wine or a tea in the morning.

There is no onsite restaurant for dinner or a bar so you have to go out for your food and drinks. I wasn't there for breakfast, so they may offer a breakfast as part of the stay

We had the most amazing stay at the Edgartown Inn, we were only there for one night and wish we had more time. The location is central to everything you'll want to explore in Edgartown. The Inn itself is absolutely stunning, very modern and chic. The entire staff was beyond helpful and extremely kind. When we got back from dinner, we sat out back by the fire and enjoyed a freshly baked coffee and in the AM, they had a little breakfast set up (smaller items) but all included and thoughtful. Would highly recommend!

Nothing, everything was truly perfect for the one night stay!

Everything! We were able to experience two different rooms because we had to add an extra night last minute and though both were in different floors and views they were very nicely appointed, clean and spacious. We loved the breakfast, fire pit, location and whole vibe of the place. The staff could not have been more helpful. Will definitely stay here again!

Nothing!